Class of 2023 Part 2: How I voted for the International Boxing HOF
I am a longtime elector and cast ballots in five categories: modern men, modern women, non-participants, observers and old-timers
A note to Fight Freaks Unite readers: I created Fight Freaks Unite in January 2021 and eight months later it also became available for paid subscriptions for additional content — and as a way to help keep this newsletter going and for readers to support independent journalism. If you haven’t upgraded to a paid subscription please consider it. If you have already, I truly appreciate it! Also, consider a gift subscription for the Fight Freak in your life.
For about 20 years I have had the privilege of voting for the International Boxing Hall of Fame. I grew up only about 90 minutes from Canastota, New York, site of the HOF, and have visited the museum many times beginning when I was in high school and college.
When I had my first newspaper job in the early 1990s and had to drive to places like Syracuse or Rochester to cover a high school state playoff game in whatever sports season was going on I would often build time into my travel schedule and stop at the HOF, which is right off the highway, to look around for a bit.
So to now be an elector all these years later, I consider it a tremendous honor and I look forward to receiving the ballots each fall. I also dread it.
It’s an honor because I get to be a small part of shaping the history of the great sport of boxing with my votes. But it is also a thankless task because there are more worthy candidates than we are allowed to vote for and even fewer are elected. But I do the best that I can. I take it seriously. I do my homework. I review the candidates’ resumes. I also go by my own decades of experience covering boxing and knowing most of the people I vote for.
I sent my ballots back before the Oct. 31 deadline and on Wednesday the results of the election for the class of 2023 will be revealed. The induction ceremonies will take place at the museum on June 11 during the annual HOF weekend, an event that should be on the bucket list of every boxing fan.
On Tuesday, in Part 1, I revealed my votes and reasons for my votes in the modern men’s and modern women’s categories. In today’s Part 2, I will reveal how I voted in the three additional categories I vote in: non-participants, observers and old-timers (late era). See below for my detailed explanation of my votes and photos of my official ballots.
Non-participants
From the 29-person ballot, electors can vote for up to five and the top three will be elected. This is always a tough category because it covers so many different roles in the sport, including trainers, promoters, matchmakers, referees, judges, publicists, ring announcers, cutmen, etc.
Not that it is a hard rule I have, but all things being equal I usually try to vote for the most deserving (in my view) person in each realm, meaning a trainer, a promoter, a publicist, that sort of thing.